Shadow of Mordor, An Unpopular Opinion


For this review I feel that I must start off with a disclaimer due to the fact that my experience with this game differs so greatly from the great majority of reviews that have been publicized. I am not a fan of the combat mechanics in the Batman game nor was I overjoyed with everything from the Assassins Creed series so in that respect I am no fan of The Shadow of Mordor.

This game seems to me to have ridden the tide of the other The Lord of The Rings content and benefited from the long June thru September game drought, after which we`d play anything. Believe me I am well aware of it’s positive reviews and metacritic ratings. Futhermore, I know gamers and journalists have described the game as “Ground Breaking”, “Innovative”, and “Beyond All Expectations”. Despite popular opinion the best thing I can say about it is that it is mediocre at best.

For those that have not played the game or have not seen game play videos I consider Shadow of Mordor to be a simplified Assassin’s Creed game type in addition, one that lacks the story strengths that AC has. And saying that in reference to AC is much akin to saying it has as much free content as Call Of Duty game.

In game you are placed in the very agile shoes (there is NO fall damage) of Talion the Ranger of the Black gate who has the unfortunate fate of seeing his family slaughtered before his own eyes, before his own life is cut down by the evil forces of Sauron. Not unpredictably his body is resurrected by the Wraith of Vengeance and off they go in typical fashion to kill everything they can. I say They, because you often shift from one to the other, as the lack of any kind of fall damage is written off to the fact that the wraith takes over when you leap off of a tower, and gives you back your body just a moment after you hit the ground. You can also shift into the wraith to scale checkpoint towers which appear as ruins to your mortal eyes. As such, the term “mortal” is used rather loosely in this game.

You do, however, have the option to interrogate Orcs just before you decapitate them.

The interrogation part, and things attached to it, is what apparently made this game so revolutionary. Around the flowery fields of Mordor, there is a mass of Orcs, Orc Captains, Orc Chieftains  and so on… The idea behind this was to show how Mordor is an “alive” world, where there are constant fluctuations in the Orc ranks, and you will often find captains kill each other and advance through ranks, or take over positions of the ones you have slain… So when you interrogate an orc captive, you can find out where a particular captain is, what are his strengths and weaknesses and all those interesting facts… Sounds awesome, right ? – Well it’s NOT.

This is just a very nice idea, but I do not think it was carried out properly, it just did not convince me that it is me hacking and slashing orcs mattered much. No matter if you kill captains or not, random fluctuations in the ranks happen, of course this is all just a small animation that you get so you are not phased one bit by which captain is where. Now you might notice how their strength, aka power, grows when they kill each other – and claim how they become tougher enemies. But they dont, power means absolutely nil in this game, since each ork captain is killed with just spamming your mouse buttons – I will get to that in a bit. The whole world being “alive” is not how Skyrim, for example, was a living organism, where things seemed to continue happening no matter were you there to directly influence them, but its more the way AC works, guards patrol back and forth – period.


I said, every captain is killed with just spamming your mouse buttons. And that is how basically all combat in this game works. You have your auto-targeting attack, and your counter-attack of doom. One is left click, the other one is right. And when you get into a fight with 50+ orcs, you can pretty much browse facebook on your phone, as long as you spam Left-Right a billion times per minute, and you will beat the orcish forces. There are a few enemies which require you to leap over them, or stun before you hit them, but the AI is so bad and combat is so easy, that these situations are barely worth mentioning. And if that was not enough, any combat can be escaped by running up a building wall… Yes, if you run up a wall, and simply swing to hold yourself on the other side, 50 orcs will become oblivious of your existence in a matter of seconds, and you will be able to reengage your Captain alone.

This is the main reason I couldnt give this game more then 20 hours of gameplay. We have a policy here on TwentyOz to really play through the games we review, but when something feels like a WoW Fishing Grind from the first minute of the game, I’m sorry but I just couldnt do it anymore…  The story aspect of the game seems really secondary. You can run to these instanced missions and do them, but other then earning a small amount of upgrade points, there just isn’t much more that happens. I hardly felt like I am doing anything in the world that’s worth of calling it an accomplishment, besides cutting down the infinite population of Orcs.

The terrain is just bleak… In the first area of the game there are about 6 or 7 parts of Mordor that look almost exactly the same, with one orc “city” and some fortresses… When you run around, it feels like an endless treadmill, a rail-shooter if you will, where orcs slam into you, you kill them and then keep on running.  You advance the story, it looks like you might get into the next area, you get all excited, and… it’s exactly the same, with slightly more elevation points here and there, and with something that resembled grass over certain patches of rocks and dirt. Bleak is fine, but reusing the maps to the point there may as well not be extra maps is kind of disappointing.


I dont know… Maybe somebody will say “Well if you played the whole game you would see how amazing it is”, and it may be that such is true… but I just can’t do it. This game is painful to even think about, let alone play for me. I get into it, and I already feel like its a chore to play, to push on and try to see if there is anything fun. The upgrade system is okay, but when everything is attached to combat – which is horrible to begin with, I don’t really feel excited when I increase my health pool, or get another spirit arrow for the Overpowered Bow of Genocide, which has the focus ( slow motion ) ability, where you can headshot kill 6 orcs before they even run up to you.

Also there are so many spirit arrows to loot around, that it feels the Persian Army from 300 might run out of arrows before you manage to. There are a few upgrades that affect your gameplay, for example a move to shadowstep to your opponents and stun or kill them before they can react, or sprint faster, but Shadow of Mordor hardly needs things that make it even easier to kill.

I don’t know, honestly. It’s beyond me how this game is praised left and right, earning up to 9/10 with certain reviewers. Since I am one of the few that finds its so utterly bad, the problem might be inside of me, but alas this is my opinion and my review.

Is Shadow of Mordor worth the money in my opinion? No. While 20oz discourages pirating games, I would have to say it’s so bad it’s not even worth pirating it for free. This is the kind of game that to pay me to play it still wouldn’t make it enjoyable.

Is it possible I have simply lost my mind? Perhaps. I dont know. Maybe it somehow magically turns good near the end. If so, please let me know, but I don’t see it happening.

About Aleksandar Markovic

A Game Design Student, Senior year, from Serbia. Gaming purist of the new Age, quick to judge but also one to let his hype grow and build up in expecting a new marvel. Mass Effect. Neverwinter Nights. Elder Scrolls. - tell me I am wrong ?
Bookmark the permalink.
  • Nerve Man

    Wow this goes against the grain of just about everything I have read about the game. Curious and interesting. I don’t play it but the review seems honest. Sorry you didn’t like it.

    • Alexandar Markovic

      IT just failed on one-too-many things for me to enjoy it, but I presume there must be people out there who will find it just up their alley :) If you do play it, hit me up with what you think about it !

      Thanks for leaving a comment !

  • Haxorico

    Hello Alex and thank you for the review and your honest opinion, not going with the stream is important for a reviewer.
    Still, it looks to me like a lot of hatred was made in the post, due to your feelings of anger from being FORCED(?) to play the game, I could be wrong, just a feeling.
    I agree with many of the stuff mentioned and disapointed you didn’t mention some other problems that are in plain sight.
    There is no mention on the pacing of the game, the reason Talion and his family are getting killed, it is vital to the story, at what part of the timeline the story is happening? (from what I can tell it is after the hobbit and golom lst his ring, and before LOTR as the ring isn’t destroyed), the riding (it is just bad in my opinion), the nemesis system (which was a big part of the game), the boss fights (very bad in my opinion), were the systems implemented well (not if you like them, but do they work as intended. If I like arkham style fighting, i want to know if it is done well in the game, as many other games failed), length of the game, the way you get upgrades (there are normal upgrades, the weapon upgrades and the weapon runes), The rune system, does it have multi-player, the requirements to run the game, controls, the port itself (I think it was ported.. not sure, also not mentioned..)
    I look at what I write and it looks very very long so I stopped. mainly all you said is that you hate the game, but not how the game works. If I am thinking about buying the game, you need to mention these fields, those are very important for my decision, and if you can’t go through with the game and it is painful to you, why not let some one else review it?
    Think if a new play to DotA (2) would make a review based on 20 hours of the game. He would probably get his ass handed to him, wont like the game and make a bad review (or a rant) and I am sorry, but this review looks the same.

    Please don’t take this post as somthing against you as a person or a reviewer/game critic. This is about making the next review better and I hope you will take some of the information from this post in mind.
    Haxorico 😉

    • Alexandar Markovic

      Hello, and thanks for taking the time to read and comment,

      I cannot reply with much, besides saying as I did above, that the review came off my disappointment with the game after seeing others review it as 9/10, groundbreaking, innovative and w/e else.
      I wanted more to point-out the flaws and bad features that 99% of people who did reviews on the game either missed, or failed to mention, and give my opinion on it.

      You are right in terms of not going deep into how the game works, but if I found the game worth even playing, I would have probably been more inspired to explain more about it.

      Again, thanks for reading the review – and dont shy away from disagreeing with me, or telling me about it :)

      • Haxorico

        That is completly understood, We share many of the opinions regarding the game, even tough I think it is a good game as a whole. I think what we have here is a rant more than a review, and so I was offering some extra stuff, you might update this in the future, or maybe make sure the next review will have some of the above suggestions.
        Regarding the situation, I recommend you check out what Angry Joe does (If this is not allowed as I am advertising him in some way, please remove my comment, not my intention).
        If the game pisses him off to a great level (seems like what you had here) he makes a rant video (well he makes reviews as videos, you can make an article I guess), and then, after he let loose some steam(get it? steam…) he then goes on to a review at a seperate place (well, video).
        TotalBiscuit does the same from time to time. At the top of my mind are the videos he made about Dead Rising 3, and I think he also did a seperate video regarding other aspects that he thought the viewer should know.

        Hating on a game is one thing, actually in this case, it is even good, you point out the bad side of the game that a viewer may very well share (like me) But you have to give credit to the game when he does something right. You may not like the arkham fighting style, but it is done very well (in my opinion). As a game critic I think it is your duty for the readers to point what you think of the game and take as many aspects as needed to point them out, and only at the end to give your final conclusion.
        For example, you stated that the entire game (upgrades, quests, free roaming, the orc captains) are all around the fighting. If you enjoyed the fighting at the batman arkham games, you will most likely enjoy this game as well, and vice versa (you being the other way around, and not everyone enjoy that, and that is completly understood, we all have opinions)

        Just some suggestions for the future. Good luck on your way to becoming a game critic (or reviewer or what ever you call it ;)) and I hope to see more reviews from you.

  • Elvick

    I’ve enjoyed what I’ve played so far. But I do enjoy the Batman Arkham series and AC (to a point, the combat in AC is awful, but I love to traverse in it).

    If someone has a PS4 and a friend with a PS4 and that friend has this game, I’d recommend they try it with Share Play. I did this with a friend who lives in Florida (I’m in British Columbia), and that got me to go pick up the game because I enjoyed it so much.

    The only real issue I have with the game, so far, is the controls. They just don’t feel very intuitive, feels like they could’ve been mapped better to a controller. Otherwise, I’m enjoying it.

    • Alexandar Markovic

      Its great that you are enjoying the game, nothing worse then spending money on one and then not getting what you expected.

      If I get a chance to try it on a PS4, I might give it another shot and see if it improves the overall feeling.

      Thanks for taking the time to comment mate, its always appreciated :)